
As we get ready for another football season, I’d like to take some time to deliver a little wisdom to many football fans out there. It is said that the most popular man in any town is the back-up quarterback. At the first sight of trouble, we go looking for help from good old number two. “Bring in the deuce,” we’ll say, “he’ll turn this around.” Well, I’m here to tell you that’s exactly what he is, deuce, or in other words: He’s shit.
That’s right, your back-up quarterback sucks.
Nonetheless, the allure of the back-up persists. I recall just a season ago hearing numerous Giants fans who otherwise seemed like reasonable enough folks, insist that at 9-4 it was time to “give Lorenzen a look.” That’s Jared Lorenzen – who was the third string QB by the way – the "Hefty Lefty" out of Kentucky, who would have added the bonus of not only performing terribly, but with the added distinction of making the Giants the only team in the league with a starting quarterback who was clinically obese. You also might have noticed that we went on to win the Super Bowl. Somehow, I don’t see Lorenzen shaking out of trouble during the “Catch 42," er the “Flea to Tyree,” um, I mean, the “Immaculate Connection,” fuck, nothing really ever stuck there, did it?
Obviously, these men holding clipboards are all supremely talented, they are in the NFL. If you were to have a catch with any of them, you’d likely leave with at least 4-7 broken fingers, and I would guess that even a man as oddly shaped as Lorenzen would leave you shocked at his relative quickness. That being said, in the context of an NFL game, they stink. They’re terrible. Awful. Not good. Bad.
You are never the back-up away from turning the season around, in fact, you are the back-up away from spending Sundays with your girlfriend at West Elm looking for a duvet cover that goes better with the curtains. Sure, there’s the occasional diamond in the rough, the Drew Bledsoe/Tom Brady miraculous discovery, a Derek Anderson here, a Jeff Garcia there, but usually even if you are lucky enough to have Todd Collins scrape out a few victories, eventually the bloom on that rose is likely to fade and you wake up and Danny Kanell is still your starting quarterback...for years.
A quick roll call of the back-up signal callers across the NFL should put this in its proper perspective:
Brad Johnson - Anthony Wright - Kevin Kolb - Todd Collins
Kurt Warner - Alex Smith - Seneca Wallace - Trent Green
Rex Grossman - Dan Orlovsky - Brian Brohm - Gus Frerotte
Chris Redman - Matt Moore - Mark Brunell - Luke McCown
Kerry Collins - Cleo Lemon - Jim Sorgi - Sage Rosenfels
Charlie Batch - Brady Quinn - Ryan Fitzpatrick - Kyle Boller
Billy Volek - Andrew Walter - Tyler Thigpen - Patrick Ramsey
Kellen Clemens - Matt Cassel - Josh McCown - J.P. Losman
See anything you like? Feel like ordering anything a la carte? Didn't think so.
Honestly, if any of these men should see any significant time on the field you're likely spending the majority of your Sundays doing laundry. And hell, maybe you do get the guy who will play well, adequately fill in, and win you a few games. That's certainly possible. They are professional quarterbacks, theoretically they aren't completely inept. But they're not taking you all the way either, so don't plan on your SI Championship Collector's set at the end of the season. The guy making the hand signals isn't some secret weapon waiting in the wings if only you'd gotten to him sooner.
So enough of this clamoring for numero dos, enough chanting the back-up's name, because he isn't going to save you. Unless your defense is truly great, or your running game superb, I'm afraid I have to conclude with one point and one point only, which is that if your starting quarterback sucks, then unfortunately, so do you.